HRT vs No Treatment in Perimenopause: What the Evidence Shows
Comparing HRT vs no treatment for perimenopause symptoms. Understand the benefits, risks, and who each approach suits so you can have an informed conversation with your doctor.
The Core Question
When perimenopause symptoms begin affecting your daily life, one of the first questions many women face is whether to use hormone replacement therapy or manage without it. Both are valid paths. The right choice depends on your symptom severity, personal health history, preferences, and what matters most to you right now.
What HRT Does
HRT replaces the estrogen and, where needed, progesterone that your body is producing less of during perimenopause. It is the most effective treatment available for vasomotor symptoms like hot flashes and night sweats, and it also supports sleep, mood stability, vaginal comfort, and bone density. Modern formulations, particularly body-identical transdermal options, have a well-established safety profile for most healthy women under 60 who are within 10 years of their last period.
What No-Treatment Looks Like
Choosing not to use HRT does not mean doing nothing. Many women manage perimenopause through lifestyle changes: regular strength training and aerobic exercise, a nutrient-dense diet, stress reduction practices, sleep hygiene habits, and targeted supplements. Non-hormonal prescription options also exist for specific symptoms. For women with mild to moderate symptoms, this approach can be genuinely effective. For women with contraindications to hormones, it may be the only realistic path.
Key Differences to Know
HRT works faster and more reliably for severe vasomotor symptoms. Lifestyle approaches take longer to show results but build habits that benefit overall health regardless of hormone status. HRT carries small, context-dependent risks including changes to breast cancer risk depending on the type used. No-treatment approaches carry no medication-related risks but may leave significant symptoms unaddressed, which has its own quality-of-life and long-term health costs, particularly around bone and cardiovascular health.
Who Each Approach Suits
HRT tends to suit women with moderate to severe symptoms that are affecting sleep, work, or relationships, and who do not have personal contraindications. No-treatment or lifestyle-first approaches tend to suit women with milder symptoms, those who prefer to avoid medication, women with certain hormone-sensitive conditions, and those who want to try non-pharmaceutical options first. These categories are not fixed. Many women start with lifestyle changes and add HRT later, or use HRT for a defined period and then transition off.
Making the Decision
This is not a one-size-fits-all situation. A thorough conversation with a menopause-informed doctor is the most important step. Tracking your symptoms beforehand gives you concrete evidence to bring to that appointment. PeriPlan lets you log symptoms and track patterns over time, which can make that conversation more productive. Whatever you choose, you are not locked in. Treatment decisions in perimenopause can be reviewed, adjusted, and changed as your needs evolve.
Related reading
Get your personalized daily plan
Track symptoms, match workouts to your day type, and build a routine that adapts with you through every phase of perimenopause.