Keto vs Mediterranean Diet for Perimenopause: Which One Actually Helps?
Keto vs Mediterranean diet for perimenopause: insulin resistance, weight, hormones, cognition, inflammation, and sustainability compared. Honest and evidence-based.
Why Your Diet Might Need to Change During Perimenopause
If you've been eating the same way for years and suddenly your body isn't responding the same way, you're not imagining it. Perimenopause changes how your body handles food, stores fat, and uses energy. Declining estrogen levels increase insulin resistance, meaning your cells become less efficient at using glucose. Muscle mass begins to decline, which slows your resting metabolism. Fat distribution shifts toward the abdomen. These changes are real, they're hormonal, and they mean that dietary strategies that worked in your 30s may need some updating. Two diets come up most often in perimenopause discussions: keto and Mediterranean. Here's an honest look at what each does and who each works best for.
The Ketogenic Diet: How It Works
A ketogenic diet is very low in carbohydrates, typically under 20 to 50 grams of net carbs per day, moderate in protein, and high in fat. When carbohydrate intake drops this low, your body depletes its glucose stores and switches to burning fat for fuel, producing molecules called ketones. This metabolic state, ketosis, directly addresses insulin resistance by removing carbohydrates from the equation. Blood sugar stays lower and more stable because there's less glucose coming in. Some research suggests this can be particularly beneficial during perimenopause when insulin resistance increases. Studies have examined keto approaches in peri and postmenopausal women and found notable improvements in fasting insulin levels, triglycerides, and abdominal fat reduction.
The Mediterranean Diet: How It Works
The Mediterranean diet is not low-carb. It emphasizes vegetables, fruits, legumes, whole grains, olive oil, nuts, fish, and moderate amounts of dairy and poultry, with red meat and processed foods minimized. It is rich in fiber, healthy fats, antioxidants, and anti-inflammatory compounds. Rather than eliminating carbohydrate food groups, it focuses on food quality and pattern. The evidence base for the Mediterranean diet is among the strongest in nutrition research across a wide range of health outcomes, including cardiovascular disease, cognitive decline, metabolic health, and longevity. In perimenopause specifically, research has associated Mediterranean-style eating with lower rates of hot flash severity, better mood outcomes, and reduced inflammation.
Head-to-Head: Insulin Resistance and Weight
On insulin resistance, keto has an edge for speed. By dramatically reducing carbohydrate intake, it lowers blood glucose and insulin levels quickly and significantly. For people whose perimenopausal weight gain is driven heavily by insulin resistance, this can produce notable results in weeks. Mediterranean diet also improves insulin sensitivity, but more gradually, through fiber, healthy fats, and reducing processed food rather than eliminating carbohydrates. For long-term weight management, the comparison is more even. Research consistently shows that adherence to a dietary pattern matters more than the pattern itself. A Mediterranean diet you sustain for years outperforms a keto diet you abandon after three months. Keto can be harder to maintain because it requires constant carbohydrate vigilance and can create social friction around food.
Cognitive Effects and Brain Health
Brain fog, memory lapses, and word-finding difficulties are among the most distressing perimenopausal symptoms. Both diets offer something relevant here. Ketones are a highly efficient fuel for the brain, and some research suggests that a ketogenic state may improve mental clarity, particularly for people whose brains have become somewhat insulin resistant. Some women report sharper cognition after a few weeks of keto, once the initial adjustment phase passes. Mediterranean diet's cognitive benefit comes through a different route: its anti-inflammatory compounds, healthy fats including omega-3s from fish, and protective polyphenols from vegetables and olive oil are associated with reduced cognitive decline over time. For acute cognitive symptoms in perimenopause, the short-term evidence slightly favors keto. For long-term brain health, Mediterranean diet has a longer track record.
Inflammation and Hormonal Effects
Inflammation is a significant driver of perimenopausal symptoms. Rising levels of inflammatory markers in midlife correlate with more severe hot flashes, worse mood outcomes, and increased cardiovascular risk. Mediterranean diet has decades of research behind its anti-inflammatory effects. Its combination of omega-3 fatty acids, polyphenols, fiber, and low levels of processed foods creates a broadly anti-inflammatory dietary pattern. Keto can also reduce inflammation, partly through the direct anti-inflammatory effects of ketones and partly through reducing blood sugar spikes. The evidence base for keto's anti-inflammatory effects is smaller and more recent. On hormone levels specifically, neither diet dramatically changes estrogen or progesterone levels, but both can affect the hormonal environment indirectly through their effects on insulin, cortisol, and body fat, since adipose tissue produces some estrogen.
Muscle Maintenance: A Critical Consideration
During perimenopause, muscle mass declines faster than at any previous point in your life. This is partly hormonal and partly a natural aging process, but diet influences how much you lose and how well you preserve and build muscle. Mediterranean diet, with its moderate protein from fish, legumes, and dairy, combined with adequate carbohydrates to fuel strength training, generally supports muscle preservation well. Keto requires careful attention to protein intake. If protein is too low, the body can break down muscle for glucose in a process called gluconeogenesis. Getting adequate protein on a ketogenic diet for muscle preservation requires intentional planning. Both diets can support muscle maintenance, but Mediterranean's inclusion of carbohydrates may make it easier to fuel the strength training that is the most important single intervention for muscle preservation during perimenopause.
Sustainability and Who Each Suits Best
Keto suits people who have significant insulin resistance, respond well to the structure of a clearly defined eating pattern, and find that their energy and focus improve in ketosis. It requires more food planning and label reading and can be challenging in social situations where you don't control what's available. It also requires some adjustment time, typically one to three weeks, during which energy and mood can dip. Mediterranean diet suits people who want broad protection, enjoy varied whole foods, and prefer a pattern they can follow at restaurants and social events without special accommodations. It's flexible enough to accommodate different cuisines and cultural food traditions. PeriPlan's daily check-in feature lets you log what you're eating and note how your energy, mood, and sleep respond, so you can see which pattern is actually moving the needle for you, not just in theory.
How to Decide
If you have strong insulin resistance, significant abdominal weight gain, or blood sugar issues, a trial of keto with medical supervision may be worth exploring, especially if you've tried lower-fat approaches without success. If cardiovascular health, inflammation, cognitive longevity, and overall eating quality are your priorities, and if sustainability matters more to you than speed, Mediterranean is the more forgiving and longer-evidenced choice. Many nutrition researchers who work with perimenopausal and menopausal populations suggest a middle path: Mediterranean-style eating with moderately reduced refined carbohydrates, higher protein, and attention to blood sugar response. This hybrid approach captures anti-inflammatory benefits while reducing the insulin spikes that drive perimenopausal weight gain, without the restrictions of strict ketosis. Whatever you choose, any major dietary change during perimenopause is worth discussing with your healthcare provider, particularly if you have existing metabolic, cardiovascular, or hormonal conditions. This content is for informational purposes only and does not replace medical advice. Always consult your healthcare provider about your specific situation.
Related reading
Get your personalized daily plan
Track symptoms, match workouts to your day type, and build a routine that adapts with you through every phase of perimenopause.