Perimenopause vs Adrenal Fatigue: What's Real, What Isn't, and What to Do
Perimenopause vs adrenal fatigue: the overlap, why adrenal fatigue isn't a medical diagnosis, what HPA axis dysregulation actually looks like, and what tests matter.
The Exhaustion That Doesn't Make Sense
You sleep and wake tired. Your energy is unpredictable. Your ability to handle stress has shrunk. Small things feel overwhelming. You've heard the term 'adrenal fatigue' and it sounds a lot like what you're experiencing. You're also in your 40s and have been told perimenopause might explain some of this. The two explanations seem to describe the same thing, which makes sense, because the underlying biology genuinely overlaps, even though they're not the same thing.
The Significant Symptom Overlap
Both perimenopause and the concept of adrenal fatigue are associated with fatigue, brain fog, mood changes including anxiety and low mood, poor stress tolerance, disrupted sleep, and difficulty recovering from physical or emotional demands. Both can involve changes in appetite, salt cravings, and weight shifts. Both can produce a pattern of feeling relatively better at certain times of day and worse at others, often very fatigued in the morning and then somewhat more alert by mid-morning, only to crash again in the afternoon. This pattern is not diagnostic of either condition on its own, but it's characteristic of HPA axis dysregulation, which occurs in both perimenopause and genuine adrenal insufficiency.
Why 'Adrenal Fatigue' Isn't a Medical Diagnosis
The term 'adrenal fatigue' is widely used in wellness communities but is not recognized as a medical diagnosis by endocrinology or general medicine. The concept holds that the adrenal glands become depleted from chronic stress and produce insufficient cortisol. The problem is that this mechanism isn't well supported by the research testing it. Multiple studies have looked for consistent evidence of low cortisol or reduced adrenal output in people diagnosed with 'adrenal fatigue' by alternative practitioners and have not found it. This doesn't mean the symptoms aren't real. It means the specific mechanism being proposed doesn't hold up under scientific scrutiny. The symptoms are genuine. The diagnosis is not one that mainstream medicine has validated.
What HPA Axis Dysregulation Actually Looks Like
Here's where it gets more nuanced. The hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis, which governs your body's cortisol stress response, does become dysregulated during perimenopause. Estrogen influences how the HPA axis responds to stress. As estrogen levels decline and fluctuate, the regulation of cortisol becomes less precise. Cortisol may be higher in the evening than it should be, contributing to difficulty falling asleep. It may spike more readily in response to minor stressors. The rhythm of cortisol throughout the day can flatten, losing its sharp morning peak. This isn't adrenal glands failing. It's the hormonal context that governs them shifting in a way that makes the whole system less predictable. Recognizing this is different from either dismissing symptoms or attributing them to adrenal exhaustion without evidence.
Legitimate Tests Worth Asking About
There are real adrenal conditions that do require diagnosis and treatment. Addison's disease is adrenal insufficiency caused by damage to the adrenal glands, and it requires medical treatment. Secondary adrenal insufficiency, caused by pituitary problems, is also a real and serious condition. These are diagnosed through morning serum cortisol levels and, if needed, an ACTH stimulation test conducted by an endocrinologist. These are not the same as saliva cortisol panels sold by wellness companies. Saliva cortisol testing exists in research settings, but the panels sold directly to consumers are not standardized and have significant variability. If you have persistent, severe fatigue with symptoms like significant weight loss, extreme weakness, salt cravings, and low blood pressure, an endocrinology referral is appropriate. If your symptoms are fatigue and brain fog in the context of perimenopausal changes, your perimenopause hormone panel is the more relevant starting point.
The Dubious Adrenal Support Industry
Because 'adrenal fatigue' is popular in wellness circles, there's a substantial market for supplements marketed as adrenal support. These typically contain a mix of adaptogens, B vitamins, vitamin C, and sometimes adrenal glandular extracts. Some of the individual ingredients have legitimate evidence in other contexts, particularly certain adaptogens. But the framing of 'supporting tired adrenals' isn't grounded in evidence, and some products contain ingredients that can interact with medications or affect hormone levels. Spending money on elaborate adrenal support protocols based on dubious saliva panel results from practitioners outside mainstream medicine often addresses the wrong target and can delay getting appropriate care for what's actually happening.
Lifestyle Approaches That Help Both
The good news is that the lifestyle approaches with the best evidence for HPA axis regulation are exactly the ones that support perimenopausal wellbeing generally. Consistent sleep timing, meaning going to bed and waking at roughly the same time every day, helps stabilize the cortisol rhythm. Movement, particularly moderate-intensity exercise, improves cortisol regulation and mood. Blood sugar stability through regular meals with adequate protein and fat reduces cortisol spikes driven by hypoglycemia. Managing chronic stress load matters: this is less about bubble baths and more about genuinely reducing unsustainable demands on your time and energy. These approaches cost nothing and have real effects on the systems that regulate energy and stress response.
When to See an Endocrinologist
You should seek an endocrinology referral if you have symptoms that suggest genuine adrenal insufficiency, including unexplained weight loss, extreme weakness, very low blood pressure, persistent nausea, or skin darkening in certain areas. You should also seek one if a TSH or other basic thyroid test has come back abnormal and hasn't been fully worked up, or if DHEA-S and cortisol on standard blood tests are flagged as significantly out of range by your primary care provider. Seeing an endocrinologist isn't about validating a wellness diagnosis of adrenal fatigue. It's about ruling out real endocrine conditions that look similar to perimenopause and need different treatment.
Tracking Your Symptoms to Find the Signal
When multiple possible explanations overlap, a clear symptom log is your best tool. Does your fatigue follow a cyclical pattern that tracks with your menstrual cycle? Does it stay constant regardless of where you are hormonally? Does it worsen with specific stressors or during high-demand periods at work? These patterns don't diagnose a condition, but they help your provider understand the shape of what you're experiencing. PeriPlan lets you log symptoms daily so that patterns emerge from the data rather than from memory. A detailed, dated log of energy levels, sleep quality, and mood over two to three months gives any healthcare provider, whether a GP, gynecologist, or endocrinologist, a much clearer picture than a general description of being exhausted. This content is for informational purposes only and does not replace medical advice. Always consult your healthcare provider about your specific situation.
Related reading
Get your personalized daily plan
Track symptoms, match workouts to your day type, and build a routine that adapts with you through every phase of perimenopause.