Swimming vs Cycling for Perimenopause: Which Low-Impact Cardio Works Better for You?
Swimming vs cycling for perimenopause compared: joint relief, bone density, cardiovascular health, weight, sleep, hot flash impact, and how to choose. Evidence-based.
Low-Impact Cardio Matters More Than You Might Realize
You already know movement is good for you. But during perimenopause, the type of movement you choose starts to matter more. Joint pain and stiffness become more common as estrogen levels decline. Hot flashes can make high-intensity exercise feel miserable. And the goals shift: you're not just trying to maintain fitness, you're also trying to protect bone density, manage cardiovascular risk, support your mood, and do it all without making your symptoms worse. Swimming and cycling both check a lot of boxes. They're low-impact, accessible, and adaptable to different fitness levels. But they're not identical in what they offer, and the differences are worth understanding.
Swimming: What Makes It Unique
Swimming is genuinely unusual as an exercise form because water changes everything. Buoyancy reduces the effective weight your joints bear, making it one of the most accessible forms of cardio for people with hip, knee, or back pain. The resistance of water also provides a full-body workout without the impact of land-based exercise. You use your arms, core, and legs simultaneously, which means you're getting cardiovascular benefit alongside muscle engagement across multiple groups. The cooling effect of water is a genuine advantage during perimenopause. Hot flashes are often triggered by core body temperature increases, and swimming in a cool pool may reduce the likelihood of triggering vasomotor symptoms during the workout itself. Many women who find other forms of exercise intolerable during hot flash season find swimming more manageable.
Cycling: What It Brings to the Table
Cycling, whether outdoors or on a stationary bike, is also low-impact and joint-friendly. Unlike running, it puts minimal stress on the knees and hips while still providing substantial cardiovascular challenge. The adaptability of cycling is one of its strengths: you can set your own pace, adjust resistance on a stationary bike, or go at whatever speed feels right outdoors. Cycling is highly accessible to a wide range of fitness levels. Stationary cycling removes weather and safety considerations entirely. And cycling, particularly at higher intensities, creates more mechanical loading on the skeleton than swimming does. Although cycling is not classified as high-impact exercise, your body still works against gravity and the resistance of pedaling in a way that swimming, with its buoyancy, does not.
Cardiovascular Health: Both Count, But for Different Reasons
Perimenopause brings an increased cardiovascular risk as estrogen's protective effects on blood vessels decline. Regular cardio exercise is one of the most evidence-backed strategies for managing this risk. Both swimming and cycling improve cardiovascular fitness, reduce resting heart rate over time, and improve lipid profiles with consistent training. Research comparing the two directly in perimenopausal populations is limited. The general exercise science literature suggests that both provide comparable cardiovascular benefit when intensity and duration are matched. Swimming has some evidence for particularly positive effects on blood pressure, possibly because of the horizontal position and the hydrostatic pressure of water, which affects circulation. Cycling has strong evidence for improvements in cardiovascular fitness and metabolic health across midlife populations.
Bone Density: A Real Difference
This is one area where cycling and swimming genuinely diverge. Bone responds to mechanical loading, specifically to impact and resistance forces that stress the skeleton and stimulate bone remodeling. Running, jumping, and strength training all provide this kind of stimulus. Swimming does not. The buoyancy of water removes most of the gravitational load, and the horizontal position during swimming means the bones of the spine and hips, which are the sites most vulnerable to osteoporosis, are not loaded the way they are in upright exercise. Cycling provides some loading through the leg press action of pedaling and the upright torso position, but it is not classified as a bone-building activity. If bone density is a significant concern, and during perimenopause it often should be, adding weight-bearing or resistance training alongside either activity is important. Neither swimming nor cycling is sufficient on its own for bone protection.
Weight Management and Body Composition
Both swimming and cycling burn meaningful calories and support weight management when combined with appropriate nutrition. There is some debate in the research about whether swimming is as effective as other forms of exercise for weight loss. Some studies have found that swimming can slightly increase appetite compared to land-based exercise, possibly because of the cooling effect of water, which may prompt the body to seek food to restore core temperature. This effect varies considerably between individuals and doesn't appear in all studies. Cycling, particularly at higher intensities or when using interval approaches, creates a metabolic demand that has been well-studied for fat oxidation and caloric expenditure. For perimenopausal weight management, which is complicated by increased insulin resistance, both forms of cardio are useful, but cycling may be easier to escalate in intensity as fitness improves.
Sleep and Mood Effects
Regular aerobic exercise broadly improves sleep quality and mood during perimenopause, and both swimming and cycling fall into this category. Exercise reduces cortisol over time, supports serotonin and endorphin release, and helps regulate circadian rhythms through light exposure, particularly with outdoor cycling. Morning outdoor cycling has the added benefit of exposing you to natural light early in the day, which supports melatonin production in the evening. Swimming is often described as deeply relaxing, possibly because of the meditative, rhythmic nature of the movement and the sensory immersion in water. Many people find their mood noticeably better on days they swim, even independent of the cardiovascular effort. Both are worth considering for their mental health benefits, which are directly relevant to perimenopausal anxiety and depression.
Hot Flash Considerations for Each Activity
For people experiencing frequent hot flashes, the temperature environment of exercise matters. Swimming's cooling effect is genuinely useful. The water keeps your core temperature lower during the workout, which may reduce vasomotor triggers. Many women find they can train more comfortably in a pool during hot flash-heavy periods than they can on land. Cycling indoors on a stationary bike allows you to use a fan and control the temperature, which makes it similarly manageable if you have that setup. Outdoor cycling in hot weather can trigger hot flashes just as other land-based exercise does. If you primarily cycle outdoors, timing your rides for cooler parts of the day and dressing in moisture-wicking, temperature-regulating layers helps. PeriPlan's workout and symptom logging can help you identify whether your exercise timing or type is influencing your hot flash patterns.
Choosing Between Them
If joint pain, hot flashes, and stress reduction are your main concerns, swimming may give you the most comfortable experience right now. If bone density, metabolic challenge, and practical convenience are higher priorities, and if you have access to a good cycling setup, cycling may serve you better. Many people do both, rotating based on season, joint symptoms, or what feels appealing on a given day. The best exercise is the one you'll actually do consistently. Frequency and consistency matter more than which specific form you choose. Whatever you decide, tracking your movement alongside your symptoms in PeriPlan helps you build a clear picture of how exercise is affecting your perimenopause experience over time, and gives you evidence-based data to share with your healthcare provider if you need to adjust your approach. This content is for informational purposes only and does not replace medical advice. Always consult your healthcare provider about your specific situation.
Related reading
Get your personalized daily plan
Track symptoms, match workouts to your day type, and build a routine that adapts with you through every phase of perimenopause.