Zinc vs Magnesium for Perimenopause: Which Should You Take?
Zinc and magnesium both have roles during perimenopause but they work differently. Find out which supplement fits your main symptoms and goals.
Why Both Minerals Come Up in Perimenopause
Zinc and magnesium are among the most commonly recommended minerals during perimenopause, and for good reason. Both are involved in hormonal regulation, nervous system function, sleep quality, and inflammation management. Both are also commonly depleted in women who experience high stress, follow restrictive diets, or have gut absorption issues, all of which become more prevalent during the perimenopausal years. The question of which to prioritise, or whether to take both, depends largely on your primary symptoms and your current diet. This comparison breaks down what each mineral does and where the evidence is strongest.
What Magnesium Does in the Body
Magnesium is involved in over 300 enzymatic reactions and is critical for muscle function, nerve transmission, blood sugar regulation, and the production of serotonin and melatonin. During perimenopause, its most relevant roles include supporting sleep quality, reducing anxiety and irritability, easing muscle tension and headaches, and helping to regulate blood pressure and heart rhythm. Magnesium also works with vitamin D and calcium to maintain bone density, which is a growing concern as estrogen levels decline. Deficiency is extremely common in the general population and is associated with insomnia, anxiety, muscle cramps, and constipation, all of which overlap with perimenopause symptoms.
What Zinc Does in the Body
Zinc is essential for immune function, wound healing, protein synthesis, and the production and metabolism of hormones including thyroid hormones and sex hormones. During perimenopause, zinc's most clinically relevant roles include supporting skin integrity and collagen production, modulating inflammation, assisting thyroid function, and contributing to reproductive hormone balance. Zinc also has antioxidant properties and plays a role in mood regulation through its interaction with the central nervous system. Women who experience hair thinning, frequent infections, slow wound healing, or skin changes during perimenopause may be particularly relevant candidates for zinc assessment.
Which Symptoms Does Each Address Better
Magnesium is generally the stronger choice for sleep problems, anxiety, muscle cramps, headaches, and heart palpitations. If your main perimenopause complaints are waking in the night, difficulty falling asleep, feeling tense or on edge, or experiencing more headaches than usual, magnesium is often the first mineral to consider. Zinc is more targeted toward immune resilience, skin and hair health, and hormonal metabolism support. If you are experiencing notable hair thinning, skin that seems to be deteriorating faster than expected, recurring infections, or you have reason to believe your thyroid is not functioning optimally, zinc is worth discussing with a healthcare provider.
Forms and Doses: What to Look For
Not all forms of magnesium are equally well absorbed. Magnesium glycinate is often cited as the best-tolerated form for sleep and anxiety because it is gentle on the gut and has good bioavailability. Magnesium oxide, the most common form in cheap supplements, is poorly absorbed and tends to cause loose stools. Magnesium malate may be better suited to those with muscle pain and fatigue. For zinc, zinc citrate and zinc picolinate are better absorbed than zinc oxide. Typical supplemental doses for zinc range from 8 to 25 mg per day. Supplemental magnesium doses are typically 200 to 400 mg per day. Taking too much zinc long-term can deplete copper, so balance matters.
Food Sources and Whether Supplements Are Necessary
Magnesium is found in leafy green vegetables, nuts, seeds, legumes, wholegrains, and dark chocolate. Zinc is found in red meat, shellfish (particularly oysters), poultry, legumes, nuts, and seeds. A varied whole food diet can meet the needs of many women, but absorption can be compromised by high phytate intake from wholegrains and legumes without preparation such as soaking or fermenting, by chronic stress, by alcohol, and by certain medications including proton pump inhibitors. Getting a blood test before starting supplements gives you a baseline and helps you avoid supplementing unnecessarily or at the wrong dose.
Taking Both, and Working With Your Symptoms
Many women in perimenopause benefit from both minerals, taken for different reasons. Taking magnesium in the evening for sleep and relaxation, and zinc with food during the day for immune and hormonal support, is a practical approach that avoids interactions. However, high doses of either supplement can interfere with absorption of the other, so staying within reasonable ranges matters. Tracking your symptoms over time is one of the most useful ways to assess whether a supplement is helping. PeriPlan allows you to log symptoms and monitor patterns across weeks and months, giving you concrete data to evaluate what is shifting and what is not. Supplements work best as part of a broader strategy that includes sleep, movement, and good nutrition.
Related reading
Get your personalized daily plan
Track symptoms, match workouts to your day type, and build a routine that adapts with you through every phase of perimenopause.