Cycling vs Swimming for Perimenopause: Which Exercise Suits You Better?
Cycling and swimming both benefit women in perimenopause. Compare their impact on symptoms, bone density, cardiovascular health, and daily life to choose well.
Why exercise choice matters during perimenopause
Regular physical activity is one of the most consistently recommended strategies for managing perimenopause symptoms and protecting long-term health. It supports mood, sleep, cardiovascular function, and body composition, and it helps counteract the loss of bone density that accelerates after menopause. Choosing an exercise that you enjoy and can maintain is more important than choosing the theoretically optimal activity, but understanding the specific advantages and limitations of different types of movement helps women make a more informed decision. Cycling and swimming are both popular, accessible, and relatively low-impact options. They share several benefits but differ in meaningful ways that can make one a better fit depending on your symptoms, health profile, and lifestyle.
Benefits of cycling for perimenopause
Cycling, whether outdoors or on a stationary bike, is an excellent cardiovascular workout that is gentle on the joints. It strengthens the quadriceps, hamstrings, and glutes while providing sustained aerobic conditioning that supports heart health and body weight management. For women experiencing joint pain in perimenopause, cycling distributes load through the pedal rather than the joint, which makes it much easier to tolerate than running or high-impact aerobics. Stationary cycling at home is convenient, weather-independent, and easy to incorporate into a daily routine. For mood and anxiety, the repetitive steady-state effort of a moderate bike ride is effective at producing the endorphin and serotonin effects that reduce psychological symptoms.
Benefits of swimming for perimenopause
Swimming is a full-body workout that engages the arms, core, back, and legs simultaneously while being nearly weightless in terms of joint load, making it ideal for women with arthritis, significant joint pain, or injury. The resistance of water means muscles work harder than they appear to, and swimming is particularly effective for building upper body strength, which cycling does not address. For women experiencing hot flashes, the cool water environment makes swimming exceptionally comfortable as a workout, and many women find it is one of the only exercises they can complete without overheating. The breathing patterns required in swimming also support relaxation and can reduce anxiety.
The bone density consideration
One of the most important differences between cycling and swimming when considered in the context of perimenopause is their effect on bone density. Bone density is maintained and built through weight-bearing and impact-loading exercise, where the skeleton must work against gravity. Swimming is non-weight-bearing: the water supports the body, so the skeleton does not receive the mechanical stimulus that promotes bone formation. Cycling is also largely non-weight-bearing for the same reason. Neither cycling nor swimming, if used as the sole form of exercise, is adequate to maintain or build bone density during perimenopause. Women who rely on either activity should also include weight-bearing exercise such as walking, strength training, or resistance work specifically to protect bone health.
Cardiovascular and metabolic benefits
Both activities provide strong cardiovascular benefits when performed at appropriate intensity. Regular aerobic exercise reduces cardiovascular risk, supports healthy blood pressure and cholesterol levels, and improves insulin sensitivity, all of which are important during perimenopause when cardiovascular risk increases. Cycling tends to allow more precise intensity control, particularly on a stationary bike with resistance settings, and is easy to progress in terms of duration and effort. Swimming intensity can be varied through stroke choice and pace but is harder to measure and control for many recreational swimmers. Both activities support weight management and metabolic health when combined with appropriate nutrition.
Practical factors to consider
Access matters: if you do not live near a pool or find the logistics of getting changed and showering inconvenient, swimming is unlikely to become a consistent habit. A stationary bike at home removes those barriers entirely. Cycling outdoors offers mental health benefits from being in nature and light exposure that helps regulate sleep and mood, but weather and safety in traffic can be limiting factors. Swimming pools provide a reliable, social environment for some women and a year-round option regardless of weather. Cost differs: a pool membership or pay-as-you-go access has ongoing fees, while a bike, once purchased, has minimal running costs. Hybrid approaches, using both on different days, are common and effective.
How to decide and track your progress
If joint pain or hot flashes are dominant symptoms, swimming has particular advantages worth trying. If convenience, mood support, and cardiovascular fitness are the priorities and joint pain is not severe, cycling is an excellent and often more convenient option. Many women find that the activity they enjoy most is the one they do most consistently, which is ultimately what produces results. Once you have settled on a routine, tracking your workouts and logging how symptoms respond over time using PeriPlan can help you see whether your exercise habits are having a positive effect on sleep, mood, and energy. Adding at least two sessions of strength or weight-bearing exercise per week alongside either activity is strongly recommended for bone and muscle health.
Related reading
Get your personalized daily plan
Track symptoms, match workouts to your day type, and build a routine that adapts with you through every phase of perimenopause.