Getting a Second Opinion for Perimenopause: When and How to Do It
Not happy with your perimenopause care? Getting a second opinion is your right. Learn when to seek one, how to approach it, and what to expect.
When a Second Opinion Makes Sense
If you leave a medical appointment feeling dismissed, confused, or like your symptoms were minimised, seeking a second opinion is a completely reasonable response. Many women are told their perimenopause symptoms are anxiety, stress, or just part of ageing, when in fact there are real treatment options available. A second opinion can also be valuable if you have been prescribed HRT but are not feeling better, or if your doctor seems uncertain about the right approach for your situation.
You Have the Right to a Second Opinion
In the UK, patients have the right to seek a second opinion, either from another NHS GP or from a specialist. You do not need to explain yourself or apologise for asking. You can simply say that you would like another perspective before deciding on a course of treatment. Most GPs will accept this professionally. If asking your current GP feels uncomfortable, you can register temporarily with another practice, use an NHS walk-in service, or seek a private consultation.
Finding the Right Specialist
For perimenopause, a menopause specialist is the gold standard for a second opinion. The British Menopause Society maintains a directory of accredited menopause specialists in the UK, covering both NHS and private practitioners. Look for someone who holds the BMS Menopause Specialist qualification or equivalent. Many NHS menopause clinics offer consultant-led appointments that go beyond what a general GP consultation provides.
What to Bring to Your Second Opinion Appointment
Prepare a clear summary of your symptoms, including when they started and how they affect your daily life. Bring any previous test results, current or past prescriptions, and a note of anything you have already tried. If you have been tracking your symptoms in an app, having that data available gives the new practitioner a much clearer picture than relying on memory alone. Being organised also makes the most of limited appointment time.
How to Handle Conflicting Advice
Sometimes a second opinion confirms what you were told. Sometimes it offers a different perspective. If the two opinions conflict, it is fair to ask both practitioners to explain their reasoning. In menopause care, treatment is not always black and white, and individual factors like your health history, symptom severity, and personal preferences all play a role. You can ask your second practitioner directly: 'If you were advising a family member with my symptoms, what would you recommend?' This often elicits a clearer, more honest answer.
Trust Your Own Experience
You know your body better than anyone. If something does not feel right, or if a treatment is not working, you are entitled to keep asking questions and exploring options. Getting a second opinion is not disloyal to your GP, it is responsible self-advocacy. Good doctors welcome patients who are engaged and informed, and the right specialist will respect your initiative in seeking better care.
Related reading
Get your personalized daily plan
Track symptoms, match workouts to your day type, and build a routine that adapts with you through every phase of perimenopause.